Bonanza
Search
Shop by Category
Women's Fashion
CATEGORIES
DEALS
TOP BRANDS
Men's Fashion
CATEGORIES
DEALS
TOP BRANDS
Home & Garden
CATEGORIES
TOP BRANDS
Health & Beauty
CATEGORIES
TOP BRANDS
Collectibles & Art
CATEGORIES
Handbags
TOP BRANDS
Jewelry
CATEGORIES
Coupons
More Categories
CATEGORIES
More Ways to Shop
More
Are bonanza fees excessive?
Upvote this question 2 Downvote this question

It is wierd that Bonanza charges membership fees of $24/month + 16% commission on sales. Most selling websites have a Commission or Membership charge. Bonanza does both.

Am i the only one feeling hard done by this?

asked about 10 years ago

GenericStore
Reputation: 10
See GenericStore's booth
4 Answers
Upvote this answer 3 Downvote this answer

You choose what you want to pay..

Paid Membership is optional and runs from $10 to $200/mo depending on what you need and your volume (and many go with the free option membership $0/mo) …and you choose your fees from 3.5% (no advertising) to 16% (to max ad clicks)…

If you cannot support either, then perhaps choosing other options would be best…

Personally, I go with no membership (Have one now because it was a gift from a friend) and 9% because that is what my items support…

answered about 10 years ago

ccmom
Reputation: 12648
See ccmom's booth
Upvote this answer 1 Downvote this answer

Dear ccmom, can you, please, compare (generally of course) the results before with no membership and now having it?

Do you see a big difference?

answered about 10 years ago

ArtistsUnion
Reputation: 3676
See ArtistsUnion's booth

5 Comments

ccmom says: April 16, 2015

I had a Silver for several years, I dropped it when I got sick and could not keep my booth up to date..Had this gold for 2 months as a gift…on average, I really do not see much difference. Only time I see a jump in sales is when I do a massive update, and add several new listings..

ccmom says: April 16, 2015

To continue…which is what most really do not want to hear…I had another booth for awhile that did quite well, but I am no longer going in that direction, so it is on vacation right now (ps I only had a silver that one too..but did quite well)

ArtistsUnion says: April 16, 2015

Thank you very much for your answer, ccmom. I appreciate it a lot.

ArtistsUnion says: April 17, 2015

“Only time I see a jump in sales is when I do a massive update, and add several new listings.” I’ve noticed this too, but most of those views are… mine. When I post items, then add photos in descriptions, make some changes – usually 1 item can be open several times. And this generate ‘false’,

ArtistsUnion says: April 17, 2015

And this generate ‘false’, disturbing traffic. We don’t need those views at all, but there is no option to turn it off, we are laden with those views. I guess, only some membership could stop it.

Upvote this answer 1 Downvote this answer

Membership is not worth it in my opinion.

answered about 10 years ago

BrijCreativeDesigns
Reputation: 12
See BrijCreativeDesigns' booth
Upvote this answer 0 Downvote this answer

Ebay does the same thing…IF you want a membership you have to pay for it and they still charge you final value fee’s on items….At least Bonanza does not hide your listings because you don’t have a membership like ebay does..

answered about 10 years ago

DiscountDesigner
Reputation: 201
See DiscountDesigner's booth

7 Comments

ArtistsUnion says: April 17, 2015

I don’t have membership there, I’ve checked right [URL removed] if I write in the search window e.g. BAY HORSE Portrait or Iris Impression, I can see my items on the list. Do you think it’s beacuse of cookies they show it to me even on the forst place of the list? Would you be kind enough to check those 2…

ArtistsUnion says: April 17, 2015

(forst=first*) I wonder if you can see those 2 items searching from different place. If you wish, I can check some of yours, if you give me some titles’ words.

ccmom says: April 17, 2015

ebay does tend to bring up listings closer to your location…though I did see your item on the first page..after the US and then the UK listings

ArtistsUnion says: April 17, 2015

I see, thank you, ccmom. Maybe they have been 30 days fix price listings? Since they have small charge.

misskeech says: April 17, 2015

From what i have read, it depends on what part of the country you are in….you may be able to see your own, but someone else may not be able to see it…If you subscribe to eCommerencebytes, they talk quite a bit about ebay and what they do….they actually talk about all selling sites, even bonanz

DiscountDesigner says: April 17, 2015

bf I got a trial membership there, i had 0 views and maybe 1-2 sales a month, when i got the membership, BAM Tons of views and and lke 25 sales in one month. now you tell me what is going on….I think everyone is correct with them “hiding” listings

ArtistsUnion says: April 18, 2015

Thank you all for answers.

Question Vitals

Viewed: 2283 times

Asked: about 10 years ago

Latest response: about 10 years ago

To Answer Brilliantly

Remember these tips:

  • Use links to other sources to support your opinions
  • Use examples where possible
  • Put yourself in the inquirers shoes: what extra info would be helpful?

Should I post a comment or an answer?

You can only post one answer, so make it count. Maybe your reply is more fitting as a comment instead?

Post an answer for:

  • Replies that directly and specifically answer the original question

Post a comment for:

  • "Thanks," "Me too," "I agree," or "Works for me" types of replies
  • When you would like the original poster to provide more details
  • When you have more to add to someone else's question or answer

See also our Roundtable FAQ.

Formatting

Community help posts follow certain formatting guidelines, which may impact the look of your post. If you're interested in tweaking the format, instructions are available here.