2016 in Review, Annual Survey Online

As we prepare to close the books on 2016, I wanted to impart a few thoughts on what we learned from the past year of running Bonanza.

It was another promising year of growth for our sellers. The average Bonanza seller nows earns 164% more than three years ago. It was also an encouraging year for our company. We doubled office space yet again; this time we've grown all the way to an office with a view of local Mt. Rainier:

Dramatic re-enactment of our actual office view

With 25 million items listed and our sales per seller setting new highs each month, we feel immense optimism about what we will accomplish in the coming year.

More depth on the high points of 2016 (plus sneak peek at 2017) follows...

Seller Traffic on the Rise

Our 2016 roadmap for sellers started and ended with initiatives to drive more buyer traffic to booths. We made inroads into this goal on several fronts.

Our calling card has always been our top-flight integration with buyer channels in general, and Google Shopping in particular. Back in 2008 we were the first marketplace to be connected to Google Base (precursor to Google Shopping), and maintaining our lead has been a priority for us ever since. One result of our investment: in Q4, we saw 70% growth in TurboTraffic pageviews compared to the same period in 2015, and 123% growth in TurboTraffic sales. This difference was partly attributable to the number of sellers that chose TurboTraffic packs this holiday season.

Bonanza's Affiliate program has been another fast-growing source of buyers this year. We are now active advertisers across more than 1,000 publishers, including Cartera, eBates and RewardStyle. Total sales from the affiliate program grew more than 50% compared to 2015.

The most recent addition to our lineup of traffic-driving tools is probably the most exciting. In June, we launched the first version of our Customer Marketing Tool. Its purpose is to help sellers reconnect to past buyers, driving down costs of buyer acquisition as sellers build their brand. The second version of the Customer Marketing Tool launched last week, adding niceties like detailed performance metrics. This tool is going to be a point of emphasis in the coming year, as it continues to help sellers transform one-hit buyers into repeat buyers.

Bonanza sellers submitted thousands of ideas to us over the course of 2016, through both our support team and our feedback forum. In turn, we shipped more than 2,500 features and bug fixes this year. We also closed around 5-10 issues from the feedback forum each month. It was a banner year for craftsmanship at Bonanza.

Focal Point: Dogfooding

"Dogfooding," aka "the practice of using one's own product," is a mantra I’ve repeated at every company meeting over the past year. My thesis is that lack of dogfooding is what lets bad products happen. I want everyone at Bonanza to have an active booth, and to buy from Bonanza merchants. To ensure dogfooding happens, we added a weekly leaderboard that gets emailed to everyone at Bonanza, summarizing who has been using the product, and how much.

Screen Shot 2016-12-25 at 2.21.56 PM.png
Judy usually (but not always!) wins the weekly Dogfood Digest

Seeing our team embrace the dogfooding ethos inspired me to take our commitment a step further. As of this year, all Bonanza employees must dogfood the site to qualify for a salary increase. I can not say this was a universally popular mandate; nor did I expect it to be. My conviction is that Bonanza's key sustainable advantage is trying harder than our competitors. Dogfooding is the cornerstone of that commitment. If any employee of Bonanza isn't using the product, they are diluting our primary advantage -- I’d rather have them work for a competitor.

The return on our dogfooding investment has been hard to overstate. We found (and fixed) 42% more issues in 2016 than in 2015. The level of polish on Bonanza is higher than it has ever been. If any employee notices an issue, or if any customer reports an issue to our support team, we now have the systems in place to investigate and react to even the smallest glitches. You can thus rest assured that if there’s something on Bonanza that is annoying you, it’s probably annoying us too. By regularly using the site, everyone at Bonanza HQ gets a first-hand look into what makes our product intuitive (and profitable) to use.

"Most Improved" Award: Customer Support

This was a heck of a year for our Customer Support team. Last December, as sales grew, an increase in our support backlog grew alongside it. By mid-December, we were averaging four days between support ticket responses. Once we did we respond, only 55% of our survey respondents indicated a positive experience. It was, shall we say, a far cry from awesome.

In one year's time, we've reduced the average response time by about 75%. We now respond in an average of 10-20 hours, depending on the complexity of the question. As our response time improved, our satisfaction ratings followed suit, improving nearly every month of 2016. By the end of the year, we had pushed our satisfaction rating from 55% to 85%. I don't know if we've ever turned around a vital business metric so rapidly, and so completely.

The turnaround wasn’t a happy accident. Early in 2016, Mark and I recognized that a top business priority was to chart a course to better customer satisfaction. Our conclusion was that we needed to do a better job of delegating to the stellar team we had assembled. In the following months, we refined support team roles, such that we could have experts in areas like "new agent training" and "quality assurance." We started documenting the areas of the site that generated the highest volume of inquiries, and we refined these areas to be more user-friendly.

Now that we have processes in place to ensure continuous improvement, I’ve challenged the team to try to exceed 90% customer satisfaction in our support responses this year. I like our chances.

On the Horizon

The docket for 2017 is teeming with high impact opportunities.

In November of this year, we came to agreement with Google to be admitted into their Channel Partnership program. This means that we gain access to a host of fun new tools we can use to extend our lead as the best Google Shopping integration. An early fruit of this partnership will be a Broadcaster for Webstores, that we hope to have live by Q2. This product will take the underpinnings of our marketplace advertising tool, and add powerful new options like remarketing and keyword targeting.


Growing web of pieces will maximize buyer exposure, even after leaving Bonanza

Our Shopify importer is rapidly making its way from being a beta product to a fully fledged inventory synch tool. As with our other item importers, our goal is to allow a seller to remain synced to their Shopify store with no extra work needed -- just plug it in and make more sales. The importer has garnered a positive response in its nascent state, and we’re delighted about the opportunity it presents to eliminate busywork (i.e., exporting/importing CSV files).

In the interests of keeping the length of this blog manageable, let’s switch to bullet points to quickly cover a few other initiatives we have underway:

  • Live chat support across all possible pages. We’ve already rolled out chat to the shopping cart, we’ll now look to add chat to all other important pages (e.g., inventory importers) in 2017.

  • Background Burner quality. We set up a ton of infrastructure in 2016 to help the Burner scale in quality and volume (currently processing more than 10k images per day). This year’s focus will be on minimizing user time+effort required to bring about crisp ecommerce pictures.

  • Mobile app re-launch. We made some good progress with our mobile app in 2015, but had to sideline it in 2016 due to competing priorities. We’re looking to have a revamped (and fully supported) mobile app launching in 2017 (hopefully Q1).

  • Site search. Search is arguably our biggest opportunity to differentiate Bonanza to buyers, and we intend to invest heavily in tapping that opportunity this year.

  • Offline inventory management tool. More than 10% of our eBay sellers rely on TurboLister, so we were pretty shocked to learn eBay would stop supporting it in June of 2017. We’re currently finalizing a partnership that should let us revive an improved version of this venerable tool before support for TurboLister officially ends.

What else to work on? You tell us

Our call for customer feedback last year generated thousands of responses. We summarized a few of them in January. In the months that followed, we implemented every idea from the list we posted, plus many ideas you sent us that we didn’t have time to blog about.

Our secret sauce is listening to our sellers’ ideas and concerns. Nobody knows what they need from our product better than its users.

This year’s seller survey is now online and awaiting your input! The data we get from this survey will go a long way toward determining what our roadmap looks like in the coming year. Because we know our sellers are very busy humans, we’ve designed the survey to take 5 minutes or less for the average respondent. When you have a moment between shipping orders, please stop by the survey and let us know what you’d like to see next.

Thank you so much for continuing to build your business on Bonanza! We are committed to making this your favorite place to sell online.

17 responses to 2016 in Review, Annual Survey Online

  • Dengar ship thumb128
    12/26/16 at 15:03:37

    Superb work, you guys ARE the future of online business!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 14:50:53

    Thank you for seeing the true us :)

  • Genericphotowithhat thumb128
    onemanstreasure16 says:
    12/26/16 at 17:20:30

    Thanks for being there! We have experienced a lot of growth on this site. We are hopeful that this will become our #1 venue!!!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 14:51:32

    Super, thank you! If you know of anyone who would be a good fit for Bonanza, please let them know about us.

  • Bonanza profile thumb128
    burresscollectables says:
    12/26/16 at 21:52:53

    thats amazing that you were able to get a clear view of Mt Rainier, every time ive seen it it had this mysterious cloud around it.

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 14:53:08

    It is said that anytime you can see Mt. Rainier in Seattle that you are guaranteed clear weather the following day. I’m not so sure I believe that!

  • Fullscreen capture 1112017 60157 pm.bmp thumb128
    PlayfulPetPalz says:
    12/26/16 at 22:30:29

    Returned after a long hiatus. Willing to try again and see where it takes me. It was not an easy decision to leave nor an easy one to come back. But I do know that Bonanza is the best place to be for innovation, ease of use and I appreciate you all taking the time to give a more personal heads up with this blog. You just do not find this anywhere else. Since I’ve been away for a while, I’ll now have to learn the new lingo :) It’s been 2 or 3 years I believe.

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 14:54:01

    Welcome back! We have added many tools to help increase your sales (and will be adding many more). May you have many sales soon!

  • Tnt4 thumb128
    TnT_Deals says:
    12/27/16 at 01:45:51

    Thank you our Nov & Dec sales on Bonanza are up 276% over last year. We hope this margin of growth continues.

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 14:55:19

    That is really great to hear! Please do let other sellers know about your success on Bonanza. May your success continue.

  • Sunflower antics avatar 250 x 250 2016 thumb128
    SunflowerAntics says:
    12/27/16 at 07:07:38

    Just keeps getting Goodier and GOODIER!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:15:11

    Totally agree with you! Just wait till you see what we have in store for you in 2017 :)

  • 3 30 14 face lake thumb128
    razorsnmore4u says:
    12/27/16 at 07:27:51

    Thank you for an AWESOME 2016 & looking forward to an even better 2017 !!! Happy New Year !!!!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:09:35

    You are welcome, thank you! We are excited about 2017 and beyond.

  • Masonic thumb128
    masonictreasures says:
    12/27/16 at 08:20:07

    Looking forward to another bright new year spent with my Bonz family. Wishing you ALL a prosperous year filled with fun – Hard to believe sometimes it’s been almost 9 years ago that it all began. Thanks for everything you do Bill & Mark and all the crew.

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:10:39

    Wow, there is a familiar avatar! Thank you for being an early adopter @masonictreasures. May you have much success in 2017!

  • 1  2  thumb128
    Digitaltech1 says:
    12/27/16 at 09:10:45

    Thanks for being there! looking forward to an even better 2017!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:11:12

    Thank you, we appreciate your support Digitaltech1

  • Screen shot 2017 11 16 at 5.21.51 pm thumb128
    tomwayne1 says:
    12/27/16 at 10:36:31

    This is what I was most pleased to read about >>

    “Dogfooding is the cornerstone of that commitment. If any employee of Bonanza isn’t using the product, they are diluting our primary advantage — I’d rather have them work for a competitor.”

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:14:14

    Agree, that is a pretty awesome advantage. But what about our support team crushing it this year? C’mon Tom, where is the love :)

  • Beach thumb128
    happyshopping810 says:
    12/27/16 at 18:43:07

    Love it! Thanks for the update!

  • Tach thumb128
    autonutt says:
    12/27/16 at 19:47:39

    I’ve been around since the Bonanzle days and my sales have been fairly consistent, tending to grow as my inventory does.. unlike other sites, which have become very spotty lately. Here’s to an even better 2017!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:25:25

    Heck yeah you have been autonutt. Thanks for being an early adopter! May 2017 bring you much success.

  • Jenn pic croped thumb128
    jennafashionboutique says:
    12/27/16 at 19:48:03

    my best year. made a lot on this site just in 2016.

    I don’t understand anyone leaving bonanza. no listing fees, direct listing from other sites and i spend very little time on bonanza for the sales i get here.

    And i want to add. my items come up faster in google search on here than ebay. when i get a rare item i just list it on here and i don’t even put it on ebay.i have had items bought in minutes(from when it was posted) where people came quickly from google search.

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:25:45

    Mom? :D

  • Userpics13
    thirdhandshoppe says:
    12/28/16 at 08:34:50

    I love the dogfooding idea. Although I do like Bonanza I do have a consistent issue that I will bring to your attention on the survey or in an email. Hope to get it resolved soon. Congratulations on your progress! Looking forward to the new year and seeing what you have in store.

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:32:22

    Thank you for sharing how we can make Bonanza better. Who else knows how to make Bonanza better than those who use it! We appreciate you!

  • Butterflydoily thumb128
    marecrochets says:
    12/28/16 at 15:49:43

    You work so hard for us – to make this a great site—I am so appreciative of this and just love being here!

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:35:15

    We are motivated by users like you marecrochets! Keep up the good work!

  • Meezy thumb128
    Irene0526 says:
    12/29/16 at 17:23:04

    Been busy, huh? :D

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:49:17

    So busy that it took 19 days to reply to your comment! Best to you in 2017!

  • P1060802 thumb128
    carmelcollectibles says:
    12/29/16 at 18:52:44

    Thanks for doing such a great job with all of us at Bonanza.
    Looking forward to a very prosperous 2017. Thank you!! Keep up the good work!! Carmel Collectibles

  • Img 2283665 1419905334 thumb128
    bonanzamark says in response:
    01/17/17 at 15:50:37

    Thanks to you carmelcollectibles. 2017 is going to be a really good year :)

Login to see more comments


Minimum 6 characters; at least one number and one capital letter

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Sign up to save items, follow sellers, and get exclusive coupons.